No. An atheist is the bottom of the “faith” pile. A view of Romans the first chapter shows the descent of the soul. Believing nothing but what the senses can tell you is the end.
What can an atheist tell us about connecting to the divine? Absolutely nothing. He can however be a judge whether something is aesthetically pleasing. He could also judge whether the worship is having an impact on the individual but cannot tell whether it is strickly a chemical emotional response, some form of insanity or if they are being touched by God.
He can tell you whether your service is running slicker than “snot” but has no idea what the snot is. And if it is snot, well God ain’t in that, is he?